Press Release from Attac Ireland
Ireland’s deal with Apple, branded ‘illegal’ in a preliminary judgment by the European Commission, is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to tax-dodging by corporations here – with full cooperation from the State.
So says Attac Ireland, the Irish branch of the global activist group that campaigns for financial justice, including shutting down tax havens and taxing transactions.
Findings from the European Commission suggest that the State cut a special tax deal with Apple in return for job creation in Ireland by the multinational corporation.
“While the jobs created are relatively few, the loss in revenue to the Irish state is enormous,” Marie Moran of Attac Ireland said.
Globally Apple has $54.4 billion in offshore profits that have been barely taxed at all, thanks in part to a complex arrangement of Irish subsidiaries, known as the ‘Double-Irish’.
“Under Irish law, if the Irish subsidiary is controlled by managers who meet outside of Ireland, then it is treated for tax purposes as if it is a non-Irish company,” Conor McCabe of Attac Ireland explained.
“Companies such as Apple and Google, as well as pharmaceuticals, assign patent rights to these subsidiaries, which then charge the main Irish company a royalty fee for using these patents.” McCabe continued. “Under Irish tax law, royalty payments are tax-deductible. In effect, these companies charge themselves for using their own products, and then use that charge as a tax write-off. This is the Double-Irish.”
Marie Moran noted that while international attention is fixed on the case of Apple, the practice “has implications for a very large number of corporations based in Ireland for tax purposes. In fact, according to the Revenue Commissioner’s own reporting, the majority of companies based in Ireland pay corporation tax far below the headline rate of 12.5%, with some corporations paying no tax at all.”
“This arrangement is a form of corporate welfare that is not only potentially illegal but deeply anti-social,” Harry Browne of Attac Ireland added. “At a time when Irish citizens are bailing out the losses of private banks, and have faced cuts to social welfare, the State is complicit in measures that shore up the enormous wealth of the corporate sector, and erode social fabric and infrastructure.”
As part of its campaign for financial justice, the European Attac Network is calling for a global taxation for corporations, ‘unitary taxation’. This means that large corporations would be taxed as a single entity on the basis of a joint report of the activities and profits of all subsidiaries worldwide.
Under unitary taxation, profits would be split by a levy allocated to those countries, for example, based on the variable wage payments, fixed assets and sales. This measure would ensure that corporations cannot avoid tax payments through complex transfer pricing and other arrangements.
In addition to calling for unitary taxation, Attac Ireland calls for an immediate investigation into the legality of Irish tax arrangements, and a commitment from the Irish government to close down the socially costly and morally bankrupt ‘double Irish’ loophole.